5269 Views |  Like

My First Her Second

Age when it happend: 19
Where it happened: Brothers House
Langauge: English
Sex: Male
Rating: 9
Category: Straight

My brother had been dating this really ugly tramp, and she was cheating on him. Her best friend felt sorry for my brother and told him. Eventually they started dating and became quite serious. I got to know her and she was really nice and very good looking. She told me that she was one of four sisters, two younger than her, and one older. One day I was out with my brother and he stopped by her house. There was a picture on the wall of her two younger sisters. They were both very cute but the older one really caught my eye. I didn’t know it then but I was immediately in love with Terrie. My brother got Tonya pregnant and they made plans to get married. Two days before the wedding I finally met Tonya’s sisters. I could not even look at Terrie, but the attraction was so strong to her. I listened to her voice and it was like music. My soon to be sister in-law obviously noticed this and a few days later her mom and her made sure in no uncertain terms that I was to stay away. They told me that Terrie had a severe crush on me and I was almost three years older than her. I understood this completely and resigned myself to the fact that this was never to be. Terrie and I became pretty good friends over the next couple of years. She was popular in school, had lots of friends, and dated quite a lot. I knew I loved her, but I felt I had absolutely no chance to ever be with her. We argued at first when we were together, about virtually anything, and then soon came to know each other by taking long walks and talking. We would play in the pool and once I accidentally grabbed her breasts, and she didn’t seem happy about it. She started dating her first serious boyfriend and whenever I saw her she talked about him constantly. “Anthony did this, Anthony did that”. It never occurred to me how serious she was getting with him physically, and I even brushed it off when Tonya told me she had spent prom night at a hotel with him (I was sure all they did was sleep).

That summer, I had plans to go camping with Tonya & my brother. They came over to my house to go and Terrie was with them. She had broken up with Tony and I think her sister felt sorry for her, and wanted to make sure that she could get away for a bit and forget him. I was way cool with this, and we spent all day swimming and jumping off cliffs together. That night I had a fierce headache. I left for a while to go seek out aspirin. I came back, took the aspirin and laid down to rest. I woke up a couple of hours later and one of my friends who went with me was hard pressing Terrie. Suddenly, I had no headache. I went over and basically cock-blocked my friend, literally getting between their conversation. We eventually resigned ourselves to the fire, laying down on sleeping bags. Terrie stroked my arm and wrist with a key chain that had a soft plastic ribbon on it. It drove me wild. I had the biggest boner of my life. I was a mess. It was dripping like I had never known. Terrie suggested we go to the cliffs and watch the sunrise, and I volunteered, and we set off to the cliffs. We perched on an outcrop and wrapped a blanket around us. We looked into each others eyes and she kissed me. If she hadn’t I would have. Our tongues met each other. I couldn’t believe her tongue was in my mouth. The next day was a blur. It was July 4th weekend and we came back the 3rd. Her parents were having a party. I felt a little apprehensive about proclaiming Terrie my girlfriend in front of her entire family. I was not embarrassed or anything crazy like that, but I was worried her mom would not be happy with me and I didnt want that to be the place she found out. I picked her up and it was like a dream. She looked unbelievable. We went to the party and everything was cool with her mom. Terrie obviously couldn’t keep it from her mom, and if she could her sisters couldn’t. We hung out at the party and made plans to meet at Paul and Tonya’s house. We got there long before they did and one thing led to another and we started making out. I kissed her down her neck and her lovely cleavage as she groped my ass. I undid her shirt and she took off her bra and revealed her gorgeous breasts to me. They were perfect. The nipples were medium sized and erect. I kissed and sucked them, enjoying every possible moment. She rolled me over on my back and the next thing I know, Her hand is wrapped around my dick. It felt so good. She awkwardly stroked it and as I looked down it was purple, about to explode. I reached inside her shorts and she stopped me and said “No Tony” I let it go, after all her hand was on my cock. I reached down to touch her pussy again and she again said “No Tony”. Well, this was a mood killer to say the least. She then became very upset and told me that she had let Tony fuck her. I was a little upset. I left after a while and I think Terrie was worried I would stop being with her because she wasn’t a virgin. She called me the next day and I could hear concern in her voice. I had thought about it and it did not really bother me that she had fucked Tony. It’s not like I was saving myself for her and probably would have given it up quicker than she did, although she did let him finger her pussy their first date and let him fuck her a week later.
We talked and she told me that she did not want to have sex with anyone for at least a year. I was a little disturbed at this, my immaturity was thinking that she had given it up so easily to him but not to me. But I loved her so much I resolved that I may not get laid while I was a teenager. I of course realized that she had fucked Tony on their prom night, learning later that he had his cock in her sexy little pussy six times that night.
We dated or saw each other every day. She gave me my (and hers) first handjob at my house while my parents were in Europe, and she took her shirt off and let me go farther with her than she ever had. I had my shirt off and she stroked my belly right above my bulging cock. I was willing her in my mind to touch it, stupidly not thinking just to ask. Eventually she unbuttoned me, and freed my pole. This was the first time a girl had seen my hairy cock, and it was great. She jacked my rod until I came, and I shot cum onto my chin. It was hot!
Two weeks later she blew me while we were camping. I made sure I didnt cum in her mouth, but I sure wanted to. I got so close to touching her pussy. I rubbed it over her shorts and she didn’t stop me. I should have put my fingers under the side of her shorts and touched it. She was squirming so much I dont think she could have stopped me if I got in there. I asked her if I could go farther and she said no. Damnit!
The very next night was her birthday, and we found ourselves alone at Paul and Tonya’s house. We were really getting into some heavy petting. I was naked from the waist down and she had her shirt open. She was wearing a jean skirt. I had no idea what was about to happen. I put my hand up her skirt and was almost expecting the “No Mike”, but it didn’t happen! I kept going and put my fingers in her pussy and felt it just for a few seconds. I sat up pulled her panties to the side and saw the most gorgeous swollen pussy I have ever seen before or since. I had to have my tongue on it. I needed to taste her. I had never felt this way ever. I put my mouth on it and immediately fell in love with the taste of it. Terrie let me lick her for about 5-10 seconds, suddenly exclaiming, “make love to me!” I couldnt believe my ears. I said “what”? “Make love to me”, she said again. “Are you sure?” I said. She took off her lacy panties and I saw her for the first time completely exposed. I said ok and started to climb on top of her. She saw that I was having trouble, so she gently grabbed my head and lined it up to her sexy little hole. I pushed in about two inches and exploded, shooting cum in her pussy, on her pussy, and down her leg. Needless to say I was a little freaked out. I have no idea why she didnt run screaming from me, but she didn’t. We did it twice two weeks later. Then her parents went to California and I spent the night in her house. She spread her legs for me 4 times that week. The fourth time I didnt use a condom, and she wrapped her legs around my back so I came in her. I pulled away as the last spurt of come shot out of me. It felt so good to cum in her, I wouldn’t and won’t trade that feeling for anything in the world. We married in 1987 and have been together ever since. My first was also my last. I am ok with that. Terrie is my personal little sex slut. She still fucks me at least 3-4 times a week, blows me and even lets me fuck her ass about once a year (she loves it but won’t admit it). So I married my brothers wife’s sister. When we got together everyone thought we were using each other, but we are still going strong after 24 years and my brother and Tonya have since divorced.
I love you TSD!

Processing your request, Please wait....
  • 0 - very bad experience 10 - very great experience